Carol Genck

Very interesting to read your point of view! Until recently I did not know any of this, but I think I am the opposite (as an artist)—hyperphantasia instead. You’ve explained it so well I feel bad for you because I’ve probably felt/acted like your boss towards people…just didn’t understand? Best regards!

I am an lifelong artist, have a BFA in studio art but spent my career in graphic design (retired); I feel my strongest ability is being able to create realistic artwork from what I can see (but can draw to a lesser degree from my imagination if I concentrate). I have been reading about aphantasia/hyperphantasia and the lack of other senses; I am curious about smell especially as I have never been able to smell or at least acknowledge an odor! (I have had several medical tests that show nothing wrong.) I did fall off the side of steps onto a concrete floor as a toddler,  which knocked me out (but no other damage) … I have read that your sense of smell can be affected by injury? So I guess what I am questioning is whether my creativity could be due to missing my sense of smell… my other senses are fine (except my hearing at age 66!) and from what I hear, sometimes I’m grateful that I can’t smell!! :D  I started reading about these experiences in a Facebook post in an artist’s group about aphantasia, but I didn’t really understand whether they meant you could actually SEE an object (when you close your eyes) or if you are just “seeing it in your mind’s eye” (imagining, which is what I think I do.) Can you explain the difference? When I close my eyes I see gray/black but I can imagine things vaguely in my mind but if I concentrate on specific areas in the ‘image’ I will imagine/see details…? Thanks!