@jond · Joined February 2024
On “How do people with aphantasia imagine and emotionally connect with their future?”
So it's not just me lol! Thanks for sharing, David. That line about me not being ambitious sat with me for a long time, I guess in some way it still does as it was almost 30 years ago, although I now understand that it's more an outcome of the way that I think than a 'failure' as such. Yeah, 'where do you see yourself in five years' is a problematic question for sure, it doesn't make sense to me either. If I really try to parse what's going on in my head, it's not that I can't come up with any response, it's that I don't see how any 'ambitious' response I might offer has any value or merit, it wouldn't feel real. "What, do you want me to just make something up?" is what I'd like to say! The truthful answer for me is "I hope I'm at least where I am right now, I hope I'm still enjoying it because if I am I'll stay, I hope I'm doing it well enough that you keep paying me" but I realize that's not what people really expect or the level of ambition most people anticipate. But like you, David, it's about where I am and I'd say I've been successful career and relationship-wise as well, so it seems to be working well enough...
On “How do people with aphantasia imagine and emotionally connect with their future?”
You're welcome - I've learned so much from reading others' experiences here, to help me understand more about the way that I think. I don't mean to flip off the question, but to some extent I struggle to know how to answer it. It seems to presuppose that there is a single kind of motivation and our problem is that we don't know how to get it/find it/tap into it. But does the absence of it means a person is unmotivated? I don't feel unmotivated. From reading personal development books, I'd say I'm very intrinsically motivated - my own sense of achievement, enjoying a challenge, seeking opportunities for creativity - rather than classic extrinsic motivators like recognition, visibility, status or power. I could say that my working style means I'm not distracted in the present by my own future goals. Maybe that's a way to find the upside in the way I think? So I'm afraid I don't have any good suggestions for alternative routes to 'conventional' motivation, but I don't feel unmotivated. I'll admit though I don't yet know if that's just me or a characteristic of aphantasia :)
On “How do people with aphantasia imagine and emotionally connect with their future?”
I learned about aphantasia 3-4 years ago, I have no visual imagery, your opening paragraphs are spot on for me too. I would simply say I don't imagine the future like that. I was working with a performance coach for the last year and it's come to an end by mutual agreement, I think in large part because I don't/can't make (meaningful personal) goals and visualize, and so as a source of motivation it's absent. We just ran out of runway together because I wasn't identifying goals that he could support. I can have future targets for work, for output, deadlines etc. no problem, but I struggle to imagine and define goals in a personal distant future. I just don't plan goals or spend time thinking about possible future scenarios of the kind I think you're describing, certainly the kind of thing I've read in business/personal development books. I interpret my personal internal perspective as entirely in the present, I don't spend time thinking about future roles or directions or goals, only my current role and trying to do it as well as possible. I don't feel an emotional response when trying to imagine a future event or goal either. It doesn't make me sad or anxious though, I can now appreciate that it's just how I've always been. A couple years into my now 30 yr career just out of university, I remember a boss saying to me, "you're not very ambitious, are you?" I had no idea yet that I wasn't neurotypical, no understanding that other people did imagine future outcomes, but now in hindsight I think he was likely observing that lack of goal-making.
On “imagining your own face vs. other people's faces”
Your reply really resonated for me, Finbar, I can't picture or describe myself, my wife, my kids, friends, just the same as what you described. And funny that Jamie brought up police sketch artist - until I learned of aphantasia in the last year or so and understood that the way my brain works is not neurotypical, one of the things I never understood was how police sketches worked when I'd see it on a TV show. Like I couldn't comprehend how a third party could draw something so specific and kinda figured the artist was just somehow _really_ good and left it at that lol. So realizing that most other people are able to describe an image they're recalling was one of a number of light bulb moments for me once I understood what aphantasia was. Reading the forum and hearing common experiences is eye-opening...