A world without imagination? Consequences of aphantasia for an existential account of self

Fox-MuratonApril 2021

Abstract
What This Study Is About
How They Studied It
What They Found
What This Might Mean
One Interesting Detail
Authors
Cite this paper

Abstract

Aphantasia is a spectrum disorder, affecting the ability of otherwise healthy individuals to form voluntary or conscious mental images, and in some cases also any form of sensory representation. Al...

Our summary in plain words

What This Study Is About

This research explores how aphantasia—the inability to visualize images in the mind—affects a person's sense of self and their ability to imagine future possibilities. It asks whether traditional philosophical views, which often claim that "seeing" the future in your mind is necessary for personal growth, are actually true for everyone.

How They Studied It

This was a philosophical study rather than a laboratory experiment. The researcher analyzed the works of famous philosophers like Jean-Paul Sartre and Søren Kierkegaard, who argued that mental imagery (picturing things) is essential for human freedom and self-transformation. The author then compared these historical theories with modern scientific findings about aphantasia to see if these old ideas still hold up for people who don't experience mental images.

What They Found

The study found that many historical philosophers believed a life without mental imagery would be "impoverished" or "stuck in the world." However, the researcher argues that people with aphantasia prove these philosophers wrong. While they may not "see" their future selves, people with aphantasia still engage in "conceptual imagination"—thinking about facts, values, and possibilities through logic and language rather than pictures. The study highlights that aphantasics can still make life-changing decisions and be creative, even if they don't use a "mental movie" to do so.

What This Might Mean

This suggests that our current definitions of "imagination" might be too narrow. If we only define imagination as "picturing things," we ignore the complex ways people with aphantasia think and plan. It also suggests that psychological therapies relying heavily on "guided imagery" (like picturing a "happy place" to reduce stress) might need to be adapted for those who cannot visualize, focusing instead on thoughts, feelings, and descriptions.

One Interesting Detail

The philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre once argued that a consciousness without imagination would be "totally bogged down in the existing" and unable to feel free. This study challenges that by showing that aphantasics are not "bogged down"; they simply use different mental tools to achieve the same sense of freedom and possibility.

This summary was written with AI and may contain errors. Check the original paper.

Authors

Mélissa Fox-Muraton
2 papers in the library

Cite this paper

Fox-Muraton, M. (2021). A world without imagination? consequences of aphantasia for an existential account of self. History of European Ideas, 47(3), 414–428. doi:10.1080/01916599.2020.1799553

Topics

Theory & Definitions

Most-cited researchers

Recruit participants for your study

We can help you reach people across the imagery spectrum, from aphantasia to hyperphantasia.

Partner with us

Image-Free Insights

A short note from our founder, Tom Ebeyer, every other week, plus occasional news and invitations to take part in studies. Change what you get from any email.

Research History of European Ideas

A world without imagination? Consequences of aphantasia for an existential account of self

Fox-MuratonApril 2021

Read the paper

Abstract
What This Study Is About
How They Studied It
What They Found
What This Might Mean
One Interesting Detail
Authors
Cite this paper

Abstract

Our summary in plain words

What This Study Is About

How They Studied It

What They Found

What This Might Mean

One Interesting Detail

This summary was written with AI and may contain errors. Check the original paper.

Authors

Mélissa Fox-Muraton
2 papers in the library

Cite this paper

Fox-Muraton, M. (2021). A world without imagination? consequences of aphantasia for an existential account of self. History of European Ideas, 47(3), 414–428. doi:10.1080/01916599.2020.1799553

Topics

Theory & Definitions

Most-cited researchers

Recruit participants for your study

We can help you reach people across the imagery spectrum, from aphantasia to hyperphantasia.

Partner with us

More research

All research

2026

Similar eye movements in aphantasia and visualizers during mental map exploration

Takamura and colleagues · Cortex

Aphantasic individuals showed eye movement patterns similar to visualizers when exploring mental maps despite reporting no subjective imagery. This suggests aphantasia may reflect reduced metacognitive access to imagery rather than a total absence of representational content.

2026

Motor imagery abilities in individuals who experience aphantasia

Wright and colleagues · Neuropsychologia

People with aphantasia rated feeling a movement in the mind as hard but easier than seeing it, especially right after doing the movement. This suggests kinesthetic imagery may exist without visual imagery, though weakly.

2026

Fragile recurrent processing in Aphantasia: Evidence from visual pattern completion

Loo and Buchsbaum · Consciousness and Cognition

Aphantasic individuals showed a greater accuracy drop than controls when backward masking disrupted visual pattern completion. This suggests that aphantasia involves weakened recurrent neural processing that affects both imagery and perception.

Image-Free Insights

A short note from our founder, Tom Ebeyer, every other week, plus occasional news and invitations to take part in studies. Change what you get from any email.