Mental imagery and perception overlap within transmodal association networks
Abstract
Human cognition relies on two modes: a perceptually coupled mode where mental states are driven by sensory input and a perceptually decoupled mode featuring self-generated mental content. Imagined states that evoke mental imagery are thought to be supported primarily by reinstated activity in sensory cortex, but transmodal systems are also implicated in imagery-related processes like mind-wandering, recollection, and imagining the future. During a precision fMRI experiment, participants imagined different scenarios in the scanner, then rated their mental states using multi-dimensional experience sampling. Thinking involving scenes evoked activity within parts of the canonical default network, while imagining speech evoked activity within the language network. In each domain, imagining-related activity overlapped with activity evoked by viewing scenes or listening to speech, respectively; however, this overlap was predominantly within transmodal association networks, rather than adjacent unimodal sensory networks. We conclude that the engagement of transmodal networks supports self-generated mental states involving different forms of mental imagery.
Authors
- Nathan L. Anderson1
- Joseph J. Salvo1
- Jonathan Smallwood1
- Rodrigo M. Braga1
What This Study Is About
How They Studied It
- The Task: Participants spent over 60 total hours in the scanner! They were given prompts like "Imagine a castle on a hill" or "Imagine the sound of a motorcycle" and had to rate how vivid (clear) the mental image or sound was.
- The Comparison: Researchers then had the participants actually look at pictures and listen to sounds to see which brain areas overlapped.
What They Found
- Different Folders: Imagining a place (like a park) uses a different brain network than imagining speech.
- Not Just a Replay: When you imagine a sunset, your brain doesn't just "replay" the basic light-detecting parts of your vision. Instead, it uses transmodal networks—think of these as the brain’s "command centers" that handle complex ideas rather than raw data.
- Vividness Matters: The more vivid a participant said their mental image was, the harder these specific command centers worked.