This is an editorial: it reports no new study. It introduces a special issue of Neuropsychologia marking ten years since the term aphantasia was coined, for the absence or near absence of voluntary visual imagery. The editors summarize the issue's papers and link them into shared themes. They argue that the extremes of imagery, aphantasia and hyperphantasia (imagery as vivid as real seeing), are worth studying.
The Argument
The editors' main claim is that aphantasia is "not a unitary phenomenon." It is a varied condition that can arise in several ways and shows up differently in different people.
One contributor proposes three kinds: congenital (lifelong), neurological and psychogenic.
Another notes that even lifelong aphantasia varies. It can affect one sense, several or all, and can concern objects or space.
Some effects of imagery may change gradually across the spectrum, while others may appear only at the extremes.
Studying the extremes may reveal influences of imagery that stay hidden within the typical range.
What It Draws On
The editors draw on brief accounts of other papers, mostly from the special issue.
Acquired aphantasia. In one study of 59 people with self-identified acquired aphantasia, 62% named psychological triggers, 41% neurological or physiological events and 30% medications. Nearly half named more than one.
Memory and relationships. The editors call results on visual working memory "mixed." Another study found that aphantasic participants reported significantly lower anxious attachment (anxiety in close relationships) than typical imagers.
Mental health. One study linked visual aphantasia with more self-reported psychological distress and poorer wellbeing than typical imagers. Another team argues that weak imagery (hypophantasia), rather than none, relates to poorer mental health.
How much weight this evidence bears is hard to judge. The editorial gives almost no sample sizes and never says how studies defined their imagery groups. Several of the papers it discusses were co-written by the editors.
What This Might Mean
If the editors are right, research should compare people across the full range of imagery. It should also test ideas in samples that clearly include aphantasic people. The editors note that aphantasia is generally not thought to be a disorder, though in some cases it is associated with symptoms of depression and anxiety.
They also raise possible advantages. In one study, irrelevant visual information hindered reasoning in both groups, but numerically less in aphantasic participants. They say this needs further study. Whether aphantasic people use some form of unconscious imagery, and how to measure imagery beyond self-report, remain open questions.
One Interesting Detail
The editors describe a study in which aphantasic participants, unlike typical imagers, remembered symbols better than pictures. They suggest this may point to other kinds of mental coding, such as spatial or movement-based codes, that seem to be preserved in people with aphantasia.
This is an editorial: it reports no new study. It introduces a special issue of Neuropsychologia
You’ve used your five free reads
Members read everything here, and put their own questions to the researchers at live talks.
Every talk recorded, with the questions
The members’ Discord, between talks
The Aphantasia Explained course, with Annual
Prices in US dollars, plus tax where it applies. 30 days to change your mind.
This summary was written with AI and may contain errors. Check the original paper.
Authors
Merlin Monzel
Department of Psychology, Personality Psychology and Biological Psychology, University of Bonn, Kaiser-Karl-Ring 9, 53111 Bonn, Germany; Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH16 4SB, UK
Monzel, M., Kvamme, T. L., Scholz, C. O., & Silvanto, J. (2026). Ten years of aphantasia: why mental imagery extremes matter. Neuropsychologia, 109622. doi:10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2026.109622
A short note from our founder, Tom Ebeyer, every other week, plus occasional news and invitations to take part in studies. Change what you get from any email.
Exploring the experiences of autistic and non-autistic aphantasics: A qualitative study
Zhong and colleagues · Neuropsychologia
Researchers analyzed free-text comments from 25 autistic and 25 non-autistic adults with aphantasia, matched for age, who answered one open-ended question at the end of an online survey. Comments fell under imagery, thinking, and emotions and social life; more non-autistic people mentioned imagery in other senses, mostly describing it as intact, while more autistic people described themselves as thinking in words. Many described memories as known facts rather than relived scenes, and some described knowing an emotion without feeling it. The group differences rest on small numbers and a single question.
2026
What If Your Mind's Eye Can't See?
Stewart and Brick Taft · Journal of the International Society for Teacher Education
In one school, 13.8% of 94 fourth graders scored in the aphantasia range and 27.7% in the hyperphantasia range, both above adult estimates. The authors suggest teachers offer strategies that do not rely on picturing.
2026
Age differences in visual and multisensory imagery: Notes on distributions of aphantasia and hyperphantasia in individuals aged 20s–70s
Takahashi, Omura and Sugimura · Neuropsychologia
Older adults reported more vivid visual and multisensory imagery, while aphantasia was more prevalent in younger groups. This suggests that age should be considered when identifying aphantasia and setting diagnostic thresholds.